## Waiting in line, waiting on R

I should state right away that I know almost nothing about queuing theory. That’s one of the reasons I wanted to do some queuing simulations. Another reason: when I’m waiting in line at the bank, I tend to do mental calculations for how long it should take me to get served. I look at the number of tellers attending, pick an average teller session length (say one or two minutes), then come up with an average wait per person in line. For example, if there are 4 tellers and the average person takes 2 minutes to do her transaction, then new tellers should become available every 30 seconds. If I’m the 6th person in line, I should expect to wait 3 minutes before I’m attended.

However, based on my experience (the much maligned anecdotal), it often takes much longer than expected. My suspicion is that over time the teller’s get “clogged up” with the slowest people, so that even though an average person might take only 2 minutes, the people you actually see being attended right now are much more likely to be those who take a long time.

To explore this possibility, I set up a simulation in R (as usual, full source code provided at end of post). The first graph, at the beginning of this post, shows the length of queues over time for 4 runs of the simulator, all with the same configuration parameters. Often this graph was completely flat. Note though that when things get out of hand in terms of queue length, they can get way out of hand. To get a feel for how long you would have to wait, given that there is a line in front of you, I tracked how long the first person in line had to wait to be served. Given my configuration settings, this wait would be expected to last 5 intervals. It does seem to take longer than 5 intervals, though I want to tweak the model some and do more testing before I’m ready to quantify that wait.

There are, as with any models, things that make this one unrealistic. The biggest may be that people get in line with the same probability no matter how long the line is. What I need is some kind of tendency to abandon the line if it’s too long. That shouldn’t shorten the wait times for those already in line. I could make those worse. If you assume that slower people are prepared to wait longer in line, then the line is more likely to have slow people. Grandpa Jones is willing to spend an hour in line so he can chat for a while with the pretty young teller; but if the line is too long, that 50-year-old business guy will come back later to deposit his check. I would imagine that, from the bank’s perspective, this presents a tricky dilemma. The people whose time is worth the least are probably the most likely to be clogging up your tellers, upsetting the customers you care the most about (I know, I know, Bank of America cares about all of us equally, right?).

Code so far, note that run times can be very long for high intervals if the queue length gets long:

```#### Code by Matt Asher. Published at StatisticsBlog.com #### #### CONFIG #### # Number of slots to fill numbSlots = 5   # Total time to track intervals = 1000   # Probability that a new person will show up during an interval # Note, a maximum of one new person can show up during an interval p = 0.1   # Average time each person takes at the teller, discretized exponential distribution assumed # Times will be augmented by one, so that everyone takes at least 1 interval to serve meanServiceTime = 25   #### INITIALIZATION #### queueLengths = rep(0, intervals) slots = rep(0, numbSlots) waitTimes = c() leavingTimes = c() queue = list() arrivalTimes = c() frontOfLineWaits = c()     #### Libraries #### # Use the proto library to treat people like objects in traditional oop library("proto")   #### Functions #### # R is missing a nice way to do ++, so we use this inc <- function(x) { eval.parent(substitute(x <- x + 1)) }   # Main object, really a "proto" function person <- proto( intervalArrived = 0, intervalAttended = NULL,   # How much teller time will this person demand? intervalsNeeded = floor(rexp(1, 1/meanServiceTime)) + 1, intervalsWaited = 0, intervalsWaitedAtHeadOfQueue = 0, )   #### Main loop #### for(i in 1:intervals) { # Check if anyone is leaving the slots for(j in 1:numbSlots) { if(slots[j] == i) { # They are leaving the queue, slot to 0 slots[j] = 0 leavingTimes = c(leavingTimes, i) } }   # See if a new person is to be added to the queue if(runif(1) < p) { newPerson = as.proto(person\$as.list()) newPerson\$intervalArrived = i queue = c(queue, newPerson) arrivalTimes = c(arrivalTimes, i) }   # Can we place someone into a slot? for(j in 1:numbSlots) { # Is this slot free if(!slots[j]) { if(length(queue) > 0) { placedPerson = queue[[1]] slots[j] = i + placedPerson\$intervalsNeeded waitTimes = c(waitTimes, placedPerson\$intervalsWaited) # Only interested in these if person waited 1 or more intevals at front of line if(placedPerson\$intervalsWaitedAtHeadOfQueue) { frontOfLineWaits = c(frontOfLineWaits, placedPerson\$intervalsWaitedAtHeadOfQueue) }   # Remove placed person from queue queue[[1]] = NULL } } }   # Everyone left in the queue has now waited one more interval to be served if(length(queue)) { for(j in 1:length(queue)) { inc(queue[[j]]\$intervalsWaited) # = queue[[j]]\$intervalsWaited + 1 }   # The (possibley new) person at the front of the queue has had to wait there one more interval. inc(queue[[1]]\$intervalsWaitedAtHeadOfQueue) # = queue[[1]]\$intervalsWaitedAtHeadOfQueue + 1 }   # End of the interval, what is the state of things queueLengths[i] = length(queue); }   #### Output #### plot(queueLengths, type="o", col="blue", pch=20, main="Queue lengths over time", xlab="Interval", ylab="Queue length") # plot(waitTimes, type="o", col="blue", pch=20, main="Wait times", xlab="Person", ylab="Wait time")```

Tags: , , ,

1. Please note that intervalsNeeded is only evaluated once so every person will get the same value.

I’d use

```person <- proto(
new = function (.) {
## How much teller time will this person demand?
.\$proto(intervalsNeeded = floor(rexp(1, 1/meanServiceTime)) + 1)
}
intervalArrived = 0,
intervalAttended = NULL,

intervalsWaited = 0,
)
```

and later `newPerson = person\$new()` instead.

2. Don Costales

Interesting discussion. R has a sufficient similarity to other OO languages (e.g., java, C++) that I could follow most of the code.

Some thoughts. Industrial simulations are predominantly based on Queueing Theory .

Major Queuing Theory concepts/definitions:

Service Time – time it takes a Server to service a customer. You are using a Probability Distribution, which is the standard method for determining Service Time.

Inter-arrival times – time between arrival of customers. These are usually treated with a Probability Distribution the same way you are treating Service Times.

Number of Servers – nothing to add to what you have said. From your description, I infer you are using the Single Queue-Multiple Server Model.

You have covered the ways of leaving the queue pretty well; being serviced, electing not to join the queue (Default), joining but leaving before being served (Renege). Instances of Default and Renege can be calculated using Probability Distributions just like Arrival and Service Times.

Simulation Concepts:

The Big Kahuna Class in simulation is the EVENT. Examples from your exercise are: Customer Arrival, Customer Default, Customer Renege, Initiation of Service, Completion of Service, Customer Departure, etc.

For each EVENT occurrence in a model, a set of actions is taken which change the STATE of the mode. For instance, at Service Completion, the Customer being served Departs, the Server becomes available and a customer leaves the Queue reducing Queue size by 1 and starting service time for that Server.

The simulator operates by advancing a Clock and checking to determine if an EVENT has occurred during the interval. If an EVENT has occurred, its actions are taken which change the STATE of the model. After all EVENTs have been completed and statistics have been gathered, the Clock is again advanced repeating the cycle.

This may give you some ideas for your next shot at computing Queue times for your exercise should you elect to attempt it.

3. Hi,

You might want to take a look at how we create Queuing Theory models in MATLAB and Simulink http://www.mathworks.com/discovery/queuing-theory.html. Maybe it will make you want to switch from R.
To be serious though, other good measures that people want to know about queues are average wait and server utilitization (are there people standing idle). Good luck with you model!